From Dream to Reality: How Dutch Home Transformed a 60th Birthday Vision Into the Ultimate Custom Closet

Little did Tanya realize when she first discovered Dutch Home at the Middletown Amish Market that they would become the answer to a lifelong dream.

Nor did she have an inkling that they would grow into her go-to craftsmen for not just one, but six different custom builds throughout her extensive 14-acre Delaware property.

Tanya and her husband Edward live in a magnificent 7,100-square-foot home that Edward designed himself on their property in Smyrna, Delaware, about 30 minutes from Dutch Home’s Middletown location. At Tanya’s request, Edward, a retired contractor, had included one essential feature in designing their dream home: spacious closets (or, as they proved to be, dressing rooms.)

“My husband designed this house, and one of the things I absolutely had to have was a large closet,” Tanya explained. “But the building designer that we were working with told us, ‘These aren’t closets, they are dressing rooms.’

“You can’t dress in a regular closet, you know, but in these you can. They’re really the size of a small child’s bedroom.”

The Dream Takes Shape

After living in their home for just over five years, Tanya realized her dressing room needed more than size to be all that she wanted. Like many women, she had accumulated an impressive wardrobe over the years – including over 300 pairs of shoes – but her extensive space lacked an organization system to showcase and store everything properly.

“Every woman wants a dream closet,” Tanya shared. “My 60th birthday was coming up, and I could have spent the money on a big party and gotten a bunch of gifts that I really didn’t want. Instead, I spent the money on something that will last me a lifetime.”

There were other reasons she was thinking about reorganizing her closet or dressing room. Closet organization had become increasingly popular, and Tanya was getting ideas every time she went online: “Closets are all the rage now. Everyone is talking about closets.”

She checked out one closet company, but soon discovered they did not offer what she wanted. Hers wouldn’t be just any closet system. Tanya had specific requirements that would challenge even the most experienced craftsmen.

Fortunately, she knew where to turn.

The Search for the Right Partner

As mentioned earlier, Tanya’s relationship with Dutch Home hadn’t begun with her closet dreams. Years earlier, when she and Edward built their home, they had wanted custom built-ins beside their fireplace. Unsatisfied with the builder’s suggestions, Tanya sought out Amish craftsmanship.

“I wanted an Amishman to do the built-ins since I couldn’t have an Amish builder for the house,” she explained. “I had heard about the Amish market at Middletown, but I was amazed when I found Dutch Home – a company that could do all of these projects.”

At the market, Tanya struck up a conversation with John Stoltzfus, and as she puts it, “the rest is history.” By the time she approached them about her closet project, Dutch Home had already completed five other custom projects for the Ellis family, including a potting shed.

“When I have a project, I go to them. I don’t go anywhere else,” Tanya said simply.

Designing the Ultimate Organization System

What Tanya envisioned was far from a standard closet makeover. She came to Dutch Home with detailed plans drawn on grid paper, having taken inventory of all the clothes she owned– “down to socks and belts.”

“I went to John and showed him my design on grid paper. I wanted to have a perfect space for each piece,” she explained. “I asked him if they could build this and they said they thought they could. So John came out to the house and we sat down and measured everything from my gowns to my socks so everything would have its own place.”

Tanya also longed to organize her jewelry collection in her dressing room. She wanted to display her jewelry where she could see it easily, rather than having it scattered in various curios throughout the house. This led to one of the most intricate features of the project – lining for her jewelry drawers.

Open drawer lined with silver cloth and filled with jewelry

Keeping the silver jewelry from tarnishing was a concern with drawer storage. “I didn’t want to have to clean the silver when I took it out, so I got them to line the drawers with silver cloth,” Tanya said. “They actually hand lined every one of those drawers. They took the drawers with them and it took them about 2 weeks. The level of detail makes it look as though the fabric was made into the drawers.”

But the drawers themselves were just as remarkable as the lining.

Creative Problem-Solving

When asked what made Dutch Home stand out among competitors, one thing Tanya mentioned was “their ability to creatively resolve issues.”

And this project showcased that talent on several occasions.

When Tanya’s initial idea for a center island in the dressing room didn’t work, John Stoltzfus came back with an innovative alternative: drawers with hidden compartments built into the closet design.

“John had the idea of drawers with hidden compartments. I liked the collaboration when he came back with the idea after we learned the closet was too narrow for an island,” Tanya recalled. “I wanted to be able to pull the drawers out and see what I had and select the right pieces that I wanted to wear.”

Open drawer in a closet with hidden compartments.

Even highly custom projects require accommodating some existing home systems. A heating vent in one corner of the closet required a custom design to make it practically invisible, but Dutch Home was up to the challenge.

And the dressing room also contained an air return vent that needed to be preserved without compromising the design aesthetic.

“A couple of weeks before they started work, Edward said, ‘Do they know that there is an air return in that room?’ I wasn’t sure, so I emailed John because I did not want an ugly vent in the door. So, they designed a very custom vent,” Tanya explained. “They did such a good job, you don’t even notice it in the closet door.” Additional electrical work was needed for convenience outlets, but Dutch Home easily integrated the outlets into the design.

The mirrors on the shoe wall doors presented another problem.

When the mirrors arrived in four pieces instead of the two full-length mirrors Tanya had envisioned, she knew it wouldn’t work.

“I went back to John and said there’s no way I can live with looking at myself in quadrants,” she laughed. Despite the challenge of sourcing mirrors measuring 8¼ feet, Dutch Home found a solution by special ordering the large mirrors.

Craftsmanship That Exceeded Expectations

When the project was complete, even the craftsmen at Dutch Home had to admit that they were impressed with what they had created.

“John said, ‘We’ve done closets before, but never anything like this.’ It was very custom,” Tanya shared.

Attention to detail and customization on a large scale went hand in hand from the intricately lined hidden jewelry drawers to the floor-to-ceiling mirrors. The shoe wall, though impressive, still couldn’t accommodate all of Tanya’s 300+ pairs of shoes – this number a testament to the scale of organization the project tackled. (Tanya didn’t mind – it nudged her to bless others by gifting some shoes to friends.)

Dave Lapp, who executed the work, delivered a system that achieved Tanya’s vision of “something clean, simplistic, and elegant.”

The Ultimate Result

The transformation exceeded even Tanya’s expectations. She certainly never misses her disorganized old dressing room and remembers the excitement as the project took shape.

“I would peek in every day and look at it,” Tanya admitted. And Tanya wasn’t the only one noticing. Her husband Edward, whose adjacent dressing room had remained, well, let’s say, less organized, found himself motivated to improve his own space.

“I left for a business trip for 2 weeks and when I came back, my husband said, ‘I’ve been walking by your closet and it’s giving me motivation to organize mine,'” she shared with a smile.

And the dressing room makeover had side benefits for Tanya, a work-from-home business executive as well.

“It helps me get dressed faster and get to my office sooner since I don’t have to figure out where something is.”

“The project really allowed me to take inventory of everything I had, from apparel to jewelry to shoes. I gifted some things that were in relatively good shape. I donated some things that still had tags on them. The things that I gave away and gifted – the people were very appreciative, and they weren’t expecting that. And what that does to your heart!”

Today, Tanya’s morning routine has been transformed. “I love it. It’s every woman’s dream to have her own space. I walk in there and pull out my drawers and find what I need,” she said. “I just sit on my bench and take it all in.”

What Made Dutch Home Stand Out?

Tanya did check out a few other closet organization companies before she engaged Dutch Home for the renovation.

When asked what differentiated Dutch Home from those companies, Tanya pointed to Dutch Home’s willingness to customize every detail.

In speaking of one company, she said, “They weren’t going to use my fabric to line my drawers, that’s for sure. Also Dutch Home’s ability to creatively resolve issues.” And the feature of the dressing room that is most appealing to Tanya? The “ability to have everything properly organized in its own space.”

It doesn’t hurt that it’s downright beautiful as well.

A Partnership Built on Trust

So what impressed Tanya the most while working with Dutch Home? “I was just very impressed with how well-organized Dutch Home was and how easy they are to work with. Their availability was an important part of this. They made it easy by being readily accessible. I could always pick up the phone and give John a call if I had a question about something.”

Tanya also appreciated the extensive Dutch Home showroom. “You could go there and SEE the options, like the drawers. I wasn’t familiar with the hidden drawers, but Dutch Home had samples of them.”

When asked what surprised her the most about Dutch Home, she pointed to their wide-ranging abilities. “The breadth of what they can do, from built-ins to a potting table.”

Looking to the Future

Tanya and Edward probably won’t stop with 6 projects from Dutch Home. Edward has plans for a barn garage in the future, and Tanya has more dreams as well.

From hand-lining drawers with silver cloth to sourcing oversized mirrors and designing invisible vents, Dutch Home has demonstrated their ability to create her dreams down to the smallest detail.

“You won’t be disappointed,” is Tanya’s message to anyone else considering Dutch Home.

Ready for Your Own Custom Solution?

Whether you’re dreaming of the ultimate closet organization system, kitchen cabinets, custom built-ins, or any other storage solution, Dutch Home brings decades of Amish craftsmanship to every project.

As Tanya Ellis discovered, when you find craftsmen who combine traditional skills with innovative problem-solving, you’ve found partners for life.

Contact Dutch Home today to discuss your custom project – and discover why clients like Tanya return again and again for all their custom furniture and storage needs.

Table of Contents

Get Exclusive Access to Our PDF Catalogs!

Gain access to a more complete listing of our products and product specifications and options. Discover all the possibilities to customize and personalize your furniture and outdoor structures. 

Lead Generator - PDF Catalogs